93 Points Robert Parker
The 1998 Brut Blanc de Noirs Clos d'Ambonnay reaffirms my impression from last year. The 1998 is a rich, vinous Clos d-Ambonnay with generous fruit and an inviting, open personality. Crushed flowers, plums, cherries and sweet spices all flow from the glass. Today, the 1998 is rich, deep and highly expressive. Anticipated maturity: 2012-2020.
Source: Robert Parker (Robert Parker Wine Advocate) by Antonio Galloni. October, 2012
100 Points Tyson Stelzer
When Olivier joined Krug in 1989, his father suggested that perhaps the challenge of his generation would be to find another clos with terroir worthy of another Krug single vineyard. Just two years later, a clos surrounded by a protective wall since 1766 was found in Ambonnay, Krug’s favourite village and largest source of pinot noir. The tiny site of just 0.68 hectares, just one-third the size of Clos du Mesnil, was purchased in 1994, and the first vintage was made in 1995. ‘We called it ABC as a codename to keep it an absolute secret until it was released in 2007,’ Olivier reveals. ‘We even kept it a secret from Moët for some years!’ The third release of Clos d’Ambonnay, so scarce that the bottle Olivier opened for me was the first he’d tasted in some months. This is the most expensive current-release champagne, with a four-digit price tag in any currency, making for one of the rarest and most memorable tastings of all. On my first encounter, Clos d’Ambonnay reacted like no other I have tasted besides Clos du Mesnil of the same vintage. Such is its complexity and enthralling persistence that it morphed, unravelled and revealed itself for minutes after I swallowed. It reached out graciously, then paused, contemplated, interrogated, before resolving to divulge its secrets. Only after I said my farewells to Olivier and made my way back through the courtyard and out to the street did its haunting persistence declare its true pedigree as one of the finest champagnes I had tasted in more than 50 visits across the region. At a full 15 years of age, it is still shockingly fresh and lively, with an elegant purity that flies in the face of one of Champagne’s most opulently voluminous creations. Its minerality is a revelation, deeply chalky, even spicy in texture. There is immense power here, with red fruits, plums, dried pear, blackberries, anise, truffles, licorice and exotic spice as if it were pinot noir uprooted directly from the grand crus of the Côte de Nuits itself. Clos d’Ambonnay is Champagne’s very own La Romanée.
Source: Tyson Stelzer.
97 Points Burghound.com
In the same fashion as the 1989 Brut reviewed below, I have also experienced some bottle variation among the three that I have tried, yet this most recent example was completely and utterly transfixing; indeed it was so much better than the one reviewed in Issue 56 that it left me scratching my head. I can't explain why this might be but for whatever reason, the pinot-based fruit underlying this wine is in evidence because while there is plenty of citrus, yeast and floral characters on the nose there are also background hints of raspberry, strawberry and cherry nuances. There is clearly some age present on the complex, intense and vibrant flavors that possess a stunningly lovely mouth feel thanks to the very fine bead of the supporting mousse that is firm but not really exuberant, all wrapped in a lingering, cool and restrained finish that goes on and on. But what I like best about this gem is how it can deliver so much flavor authority and sheer depth so gracefully because make no mistake, this is a masculine Champagne with plenty of muscle. Note that while this could be enjoyed now without wasting too much future development potential, I would be inclined to hold it for another 5 to 6 years first. In a word, fantastic. Drink from 2020.