96 Points James Halliday
When first tasted in Mar '12 it elicited the following tasting note: deep purple-crimson; this is a beautifully weighted and constructed shiraz; the medium-bodied palate effortlessly displays blackberry, sweet earth and classy oak, with fine tannins running through the very long finish and aftertaste. Not bad, you might think. But five months later, and in the company of all the Wynnsday releases, it was even better, its elegance shining through like a beacon without diminishing its other numerous virtues. All of which caused me to lift the points from 95 to 96. Drink to 2035.
-. June, 2021
96 Points James Halliday
When first tasted in Mar '12 it elicited the following tasting note: deep purple-crimson; this is a beautifully weighted and constructed shiraz; the medium-bodied palate effortlessly displays blackberry, sweet earth and classy oak, with fine tannins running through the very long finish and aftertaste. Not bad, you might think. But five months later, and in the company of all the Wynnsday releases, it was even better, its elegance shining through like a beacon without diminishing its other numerous virtues. All of which caused me to lift the points from 95 to 96. Drink to 2035.
Source: James Halliday. August, 2012
96 Points James Halliday
This is a seriously lovely wine, with silky line and length to the vivid red fruit flavours. The oak (20 months; 50% new French, 15% new American) is already integrated, and does not dominate the fruit. Drink to 2023.
Source: James Halliday. August, 2010
95 Points James Halliday
The Wynns vineyards were planted along V&A (Victoria and Albert ) Lane 40 years ago, and produce both shiraz and cabernet sauvignon of distinctive richness. This deep crimson wine has a very fragrant bouquet, then a truly lovely medium-bodied palate, its supple texture caressing the mouth, the blackberry fruit verging on juicy, the palate very long and fine. Drink to 2024.
Source: James Halliday. August, 2011
94 Points James Halliday
Deep colour; a fragrant burst of cherry, plum and spice on the bouquet leads into a palate that moves into more powerful black fruits and licorice, the tannins round and soft. Drink to 2028.
Source: James Halliday. September, 2009
93 Points James Halliday
The bouquet is driven by red and black cherry fruit, a sprinkle of spice and some oak, but it is the medium-bodied palate that defines the wine, effortlessly conveying its range of black fruits, savoury tannins and refreshing acidity. It is, I suppose, useless to suggest cellaring long into the future, but do keep some bottles as long as you can. If often heavily discounted. Drink to 2025.
Source: James Halliday. June, 2011
93 Points James Halliday
An elegant, medium-bodied wine; the ripe fruit has returned to Coonawarra in '05; blackberry with some spice and cracked pepper; fine, ripe tannins and good oak. Drink to 2020.
Source: James Halliday. March, 2007
93 Points James Halliday
Medium to full purple-red; wonderfully ripe black cherry and spice aromas show fully ripened fruit on the bouquet. The palate has more of the same, with vibrantly spicy fruit, good depth and weight, and soft tannins. It is a fruit, rather than oak-driven wine, typical of the best of the line. Drink to 2002.
Source: James Halliday. March, 1996
92 Points James Halliday
Bright crimson-purple; the earthy/spicy overtones to the red and black fruits of the bouquet are replayed on the medium-bodied palate, where red fruits and ripe tannins carry the day. A very successful '11. Drink to 2021.
Source: James Halliday. August, 2012
92 Points James Halliday
Coonawarra was unaffected by the heat that gave rise to Black Saturday, with only four hot days before veraison, and a cool season on either side of that burst. The wine has distinct nuances of pepper and spice to the black cherry and blackberry fruit, and the balance is impressive, given its price. The 2010 has taken a price jump outside the purview of this book, but will be discounted, so watch for it. Drink to 2015.
Source: James Halliday. August, 2010
92 Points James Halliday
Good purple-red; nicely ripened plum and blackberry fruit on the bouquet leads into a well balanced palate with good texture, and savoury/spicy tannins. Drink to 2020.
Source: James Halliday. February, 2009
91 Points James Halliday
Light- to medium-bodied, but all the components of fruit, oak and tannins are well-balanced; gentle black fruits and soft tannins, will improve with age. Tasted when 18 months old. Drink to 2014.
Source: James Halliday. August, 2007
91 Points James Halliday
Strong red-purple; ripe, aromatic plum, prune, blue berry and mulberry fruit to the bouquet lead into a palate with good depth and richness to the sweet fruit, reinforced by substantial tannins for the long haul. Good wine. Drink to 2015.
Source: James Halliday. October, 2002
91 Points James Halliday
Medium red; attractive clean spicy/peppery varietal fruit with subtle oak. There are pronounced pepper/spice varietal flavours on the palate, yet the wine has adequate weight and extract, finishing with good acidity and subtle oak. Drink to 2001.
Source: James Halliday. December, 1994
90 Points James Halliday
Quite intense and firm structure; black fruits; good oak, fine tannins and long carry. Will improve. Drink to 2010.
Source: James Halliday. October, 2004
90 Points James Halliday
Medium purple-red; the moderately intense bouquet is clean and smooth, with excellent mulberry fruit and oak integration and balance. There is plenty of sweet, dark berry/cherry fruit on the palate, with soft tannins contributing to a well-structured wine. Drink to 2011.
Source: James Halliday. December, 1999
90 Points James Halliday
Strong purple-red; an exceptionally smooth and intense bouquet, with abundant rich and sweet dark cherry and plum fruit swells into a round, mouth-filling palate, showing more of the same fruit flavours tinged with spice and subtle oak, closing with soft tannins. Drink to 2010.
Source: James Halliday. January, 1998
90 Points James Halliday
Medium to full red-purple; there is far more concentration and weight to the bouquet than most wines in its price category, with abundant dark berry, spice and briary fruit. Has developed extremely well since release, with plenty of briary/dark berry fruit flavours, good tannins and subtle oak. No doubt benefits from the inclusion of the portion normally destined for Michael Shiraz. Drink to 2009.
Source: James Halliday. October, 1997
90 Points James Halliday
Medium to full red-purple, bright and clear; the bouquet shows an array of spicy black cherry fruit aromas with oak barely perceptible. A strongly fruit-driven wine in the mouth, with intense earthy/spicy dark cherry fruit; the oak has been used as a medium for maturation and not as a flavour modifier. Less opulently ripe than some of the prior vintages, but none the worse for that. Drink to 2003.
Source: James Halliday. March, 1996
89 Points James Halliday
Light to medium-bodied; clean, fresh and unforced; mid-range red and black fruits; subtle oak; doesn't sing right now. Drink to 2010.
Source: James Halliday. October, 2005
89 Points James Halliday
Medium to full red-purple; clean, smooth, cherry and plum fruit with a touch of vanilla oak is followed by a medium-bodied palate with good balance, weight and extract. A very good outcome for the vintage. Drink to 2006.
Source: James Halliday. November, 2000
88 Points James Halliday
Medium to full red-purple; a clean, smooth gently ripe bouquet with black cherry fruit merging with supple, smooth, well-integrated oak, then a firm, fresh, youthful palate needing more time in bottle. The earlier release date has not been without pain. Drink to 2010.
Source: James Halliday. October, 2001
86 Points James Halliday
Medium red-purple, but showing a little more development than one would expect. The bouquet has a distinct touch of cinnamon spice, together with subtle oak. The palate is pleasant, with gently spicy fruit, but lacks the concentration of the '96 and '95 vintage wines. Drink to 2005.
Source: James Halliday. December, 1998